3 Ways to Stop Being a Control Girl Mama | Shannon Popkin

When I arrived home late one evening after attending a ladies’ event at church, I heard both of my babies wailing. Dropping my purse, I ran up to their bedrooms in a panic. The poor little dears had been crying for quite some time! They were red-faced, hot, and mad. I immediately picked them up, soothed them with pacifiers and stuffed animals, then had them back to sleep in minutes.

Back downstairs, I found my husband on the couch. I shook him out of a deep sleep and he sat up, startled, asking, “What? What’s wrong?”

I said, “Honey! The kids were crying!”

He said, “Oh! Are they okay?”

I said, “Well, they are now.”

“Oh, good,” he said with no further comment, and drifted back to sleep.

Oh, but it wasn’t good. Not good at all. I paced the floor fuming for a very long time, while everyone else slept peacefully.

A Controlling Wife

Instances like this caused me to have what I considered “reasonable doubt” about my husband’s competency with our children. He would do things like let them toddle beside him in the parking lot without holding their hand, feed them food that wasn’t chopped up small enough or forget their jackets on a chilly day.

I worried constantly that he wouldn’t worry about something really important!

I started seeing myself as the “lead parent,” the one responsible for us all. Yes, he was out there making the money and paying the mortgage and electric bills, but I was definitely the one holding down the fort, even when he was home.

A Passive Husband

About ten years into marriage, God began opening my eyes to something I hadn’t seen before. My constant fretting and anxious frustration were actually tied to my deep craving for control. The same with my anger. When I erupted over something silly like my husband not screwing on the sippy cup lids tight enough, my anger was really a response to losing the control that I craved.

Family life got crazier, I got more controlling, and my husband became more passive. He was fine with me grabbing the knife and cutting up the hotdogs in smaller chunks. He didn’t mind if I marched the kids back into the house to get their jackets on. And he slept even more peacefully on the couch, knowing that I would hustle around and worry enough for the both of us.

That might seem harmless, protective or even maternal, but I assure you that becoming a Control Girl mama was not a positive for any of us. Having the control I crave does not bring out the best in me. Nor does it bring out the best in my husband. The more I take control, the more condescending, rude, and disrespectful I become toward him. His response to this behavior from me is to “opt out” and go do his own thing.

The last thing my family needs is a passive husband and dad. God designed husbands to be leaders for their families. He wants dads to be involved in parenting. God laid out the blueprint for families in Ephesians 5:22-25, saying wives are to submit to (not control) their husbands, and husbands are to sacrificially lead their wives (not take the back seat in the marriage). So according to God, I can’t be a Control Girl wife and mom and living in surrender to Him at the same time. The two are mutually exclusive.

How to Stop Being a Control Girl

Breaking the patterns that we put into place during those early years has not been easy or immediate for me. If you, like me, want to stop being a Control Girl mama, here are three things I’ve found helpful:

1. Meditate on truth. The truth is, God is in control! That means I don’t have to be. So many of the things we try to control in the moment have to do with trying to protect our future and make everyone happy. But I could spend a lifetime lunging for control over big things and small and never safeguard the people I love from heartache. God wants me to find assurance from knowing He sees me and loves me. He wants me to have settled peace about the future, believing He holds all of the contingencies in his hands. He wants me to have security, knowing He is working all things together for good.

2. Purposefully Surrender. Surrender doesn’t come naturally for me. I have to choose it. When I feel the anger or anxiety rise inside me, I ask, “Ok, Shannon. What are you trying to control here?” or “What do you feel like you’re losing control of?” Whatever it is, it must be surrendered to God. That’s the only way to have peace and the victory!

3. Invite my Husband to Lead. I naturally want to take control, and my husband naturally wants to let me. The last thing he wants to do, after a challenging day of leading at work, is to come home and argue with me about whether the kids can have a snack. So to draw out the leader in him, I have to stop challenging him on insignificant things. I must invite him to lead, and then respect his decisions. When the kids are little this means saying, “Let’s ask Daddy.” When they’re older, it means saying, “You’re going to have to check with Dad about that.”

Now that our kids are all teenagers, something surprising has happened: In many ways, my husband has become the lead parent! He’s much more even tempered than I am, and doesn’t get drawn into emotional debates. He’s wise, consistent, and fun with our kids. Oh, how thankful I am to have him engaged in parenting!

I’m definitely still on a journey, but when I invite the man I love to lead our family and meditate on the ways that all of us are held securely by the big, wise hands of God, I can relax and not worry or stress out so much. I can find freedom from being a Control Girl mama.

For your chance to win a copy of Control Girl, leave us comment letting us know how your week is going! Winner will be announced next week!  

For a free set of downloadable Control Girl Meditation Cards, go to www.ControlGirl.com.


Shannon Popkin is a writer, speaker and Bible teacher who combines her gifts for humor and storytelling with her passion for Jesus. She is a regular contributor for the Revive Our Hearts’ True Woman blog and author of the book Control Girl. Popkin and her husband live the fast-paced life of parenting three teens in Michigan. Connect with Shannon Popkin by visiting www.shannonpopkin.com, following her on Facebook (shanpopkin) or following her via Twitter (@ShannonPopkin).

Are you new here? You might want to subscribe to my email updates, or follow me on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, Google+, or Instagram.

Disclosure of Material Connection: Some of the links in the post above are “affiliate links.” This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission. Regardless, I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will add value to my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.” Read full privacy policy here.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. Such a timely article. At MOPS yesterday our speaker talked about “firing yourself as general manager of the universe” and secondly “firing your husband as your source of happiness” and instead pursuing God relentlessly.

  2. Rebecca ellis says:

    I would love to read Popkin’s book “Control Girl” someday. Amazing how many ways a need to control pops up in life. The book sounds thought prevoking!

  3. My week is going well! Valentine’s Day yesterday, my birthday today, and MOPS tomorrow! I also received flowers three times in the past week which is a big deal because I haven’t received flowers (except for wildflowers from my children) in 15 years! I also found out that my Mom ordered me the book, Control Girl for my birthday and I am just anxiously waiting for it to arrive.

  4. My week has been very good. Got some good news that has been gen years coming— God is so good. Visited a new widow yesterday to help her with thankyou cards. Today , led a ladies Bible Study even if I forgot my notes! They were on my bed when I got home…. just had to add one more comment! But God knew and it was a good study anyway! He always knows what we need! Tomorrow is crafting for charity at Church. Whew. Hey, I’m retired? Blessings!

  5. Brenda Veinotte says:

    This week has been a good week after a week that shattered my heart. A special lunch, flowers and a ring that I had been wanted for awhile made my day special and for me to know that I am cherished.

  6. Stephanie H. says:

    Overall, my week is going smoothly and I am looking forward to a 3 day weekend of relaxation. I hope this coming weekend I can get caught up on some reading (which helps with my anxiety) and spend some time with my daughter doing girly things.

  7. Linda Horin says:

    This sounds so much like the relationship between my husband and myself. I am 60 years old and still struggling with giving up the control. My life could have been so much easier if I had known then what I know now. Instead, I felt like I had to do it all because he never (and still doesn’t) did or do it ‘my way.’ I would love to read this book. Thanks for the blog post!

  8. Mandi Corliss says:

    I miss hearing you teach Shannon! Maybe I will be able to read your book. I’m in that controlling cycle and need to get off!

  9. good

  10. Rachel Lee says:

    My week is going great! I am volunteering at my church’s vbs and although I am only 16, this post fits perfectly because sometimes I seek to control the children in my group without following up the decision with my assistant.

Speak Your Mind